
Just 18 starts into Bryce Young’s NFL career, the Carolina Panthers seemed to have given up on the man they mortgaged their future to get.
Carolina gave away a huge package that included star wide receiver DJ Moore and a haul of picks from the next three drafts to trade up to the first overall pick in 2023 to draft Young, who they hoped to be the future of their franchise.
But after his first season, they may have felt they had made a mistake, with Young looking lost behind a terrible offensive line. Carolina, the worst team in the league, won just two games, and head coach Frank Reich and general manager Scott Fitterer were fired.
To try and fix Young, Dave Canales, who had just turned around Baker Mayfield’s career as offensive coordinator of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, was hired as Reich’s replacement, and $153 million was spent on long-term contracts for two offensive linemen to protect him.
Sadly, Young’s struggles continued into 2024, and after being outscored by 60 points in Carolina’s first two games, he was sent to the bench ahead of their Week 3 matchup.
Young’s future in Charlotte was looking dicey, but he would get another chance to save his career in Week 8 when veteran quarterback Andy Dalton injured his thumb in a car accident.
Young took the opportunity and ran with it, winning four games to finish the season and producing some of the best quarterback play across the entire NFL in the second half of 2024.
Heading into 2025, advanced statistics suggest that Young could establish himself amongst the league’s best when the season begins in September.
Bryce Young’s impressive end to 2024
It looked like much of the same when Carolina lost to the Denver Broncos to go 1-7 on the season, but Young would get another chance to play at home against their division rivals, the Saints, the following Sunday.
Young would lead the Panthers to a come-from-behind victory in the fourth quarter, being rewarded with the start over a healthy Dalton for the Panthers’ international home game against the New York Giants in Week 10.
At Munich’s Allianz Arena, Carolina would win back-to-back games for the first time since drafting Young to be the next Cam Newton, heading into their bye week feeling slightly optimistic about their investment, just eight weeks after casting him aside.
The two-week break between games gave Canales and his staff extra time to prepare for their next opponent, the Kansas City Chiefs, and Young two full weeks of further practice in a new offense.
Big-time throws are a metric developed by the statistics company Pro Football Focus to measure the number of times a quarterback completes a difficult throw into an area statistically proven to be hard to reach.
Leading up to the game against Kansas City, Young had amassed 22 big-time throws in his 21 starts. Against the Chiefs, he would produce five in one game and start a run of games that would revitalise his career, taking Patrick Mahomes and co. right to the wire, but losing 30-27 in the final seconds of the game.
After throwing for 263 yards and a touchdown against one of the league’s top defenses, Young would impress the following week at home to the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
He produced four more big-time throws, throwing for a career-high 298 yards and scoring two total touchdowns, but Carolina fell short to another 2024 playoff team, this time in overtime.
For the first time in his career, Young had gone three games without turning the ball over and was getting the best out of what he had around him, putting Carolina in the position to go right to the wire with far greater talented teams.
In Week 14, Young produced another three big-time throws in a 22-16 away loss to the future Super Bowl champions, the Philadelphia Eagles, who possessed the league’s number one defense.
Against Dallas the following week, Young would struggle against the blitz, taking six sacks and turning the ball over four times, but the three turnover-worthy plays from that 30-14 home loss were his final three of the season.
After already leading Carolina to victory in overtime against Arizona in Week 16, Young would go on to produce his fourth game-winning drive of the season in Atlanta in Week 18, throwing three touchdowns and using his legs to pick up another two scores in a 44-38 win to finish 5-12 on the season.
Bryce Young’s 2025 outlook
Between the Kansas City loss in Week 12 and the season closer in Atlanta six weeks later, Young produced more big-time throws than any other quarterback in the NFL, with 22.
Data suggests that the game slowed down midway through his sophomore season, pointing towards a breakout season in 2025.
In 2023, Young was one of the NFL’s most conservative quarterbacks, with an average depth of target of just 7.8 yards, but after their bye week in 2024, his play transformed, pushing the ball downfield much more accurately than before, and further.
Only 2024 MVP Josh Allen (10.8 yards) produced a higher ADOT than Young from Week 12 onwards, with the 23-year-old being tied with 2023 MVP Lamar Jackson for second place at 9.9 yards.
When a quarterback pushes the ball downfield, their number of completions would usually decrease as downfield passes are less likely to be completed, but in Young’s case, he improved.
Adjusted completion percentage considers variables like dropped passes to give a better indication of a quarterback’s accuracy and ball placement.
In 2023, Young was one of the least accurate quarterbacks in the league, with the NFL’s second-worst adjusted completion percentage (71.9% – minimum 50% of snaps played).
Kenny Pickett was the only quarterback in the league with a lower ADOT and adjusted completion percentage than Young in his rookie season, but Young increased to 74.3% after Week 12, rising from 27th in 2023 to 14th.
PFF graded Young as the league’s sixth-best quarterback (85.4/100) from Week 12 onwards, behind Joe Burrow, Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, and Baker Mayfield, and as the fifth-best passer in the NFL.
With the greater understanding of pro-level defenses and the improved offensive line protecting him, Young made smarter decisions with the football, too, with his turnover-worthy play percentage coming right down to 2.1% from 3.3% in his rookie year.
Heading into 2025, Canales and general manager Dan Morgan have given Young some more support to make a run at the NFC South, a division that they will feel is winnable.
Carolina had both the worst scoring defense, and the unit that surrendered the most yards in 2024, so it was important to address that side of the ball heavily over the offseason.
Potentially five new defensive starters were added in free agency and the draft, whilst the addition of running back Rico Dowdle, and their first-round draft selection, wide receiver Tetairoa McMillan, has improved the set of skill position players available to Young.
Throwing to the likes of Xavier Legette, Jalen Coker, and an ageing Adam Thielen, Young really started to establish himself as a more than capable NFL starting quarterback just a few weeks after his future in the league looked in doubt.
You only have to look as far as Allen to find an example of a quarterback whose play has reached another level with the addition of a reliable weapon.
On top of the reigning MVP’s strong five years after the Buffalo Bills traded for wide receiver Stefon Diggs, Tua Tagovailoa, Baker Mayfield, and Sam Darnold are all more recent examples of quarterbacks who have played at an All-Pro level after landing a good supporting cast.
The Panthers have worked hard to surround their investment with all he needs to succeed. Should Young carry on from his strong finish to the 2024 season, he could establish himself as one of the NFL’s top quarterbacks.